Unlike a Hollywood romance where love conquers all, Hamka’s story (and Soraya’s adaptation) uses death to enforce a stern Islamic and moral lesson: obedience to parents and community is paramount, and transgression leads to ruin. However, the film complicates this reading. Hayati’s death is not a punishment for love but for indecision. She fails to defy her family openly and fails to commit to Zainuddin in Makassar. The sinking becomes a purgatorial event—washing away the sins of pride (Hayati’s family), greed (Aziz), and resentment (Zainuddin). Only through loss does Zainuddin achieve literary fame, writing the novel of their story as an act of eternal remembrance.